Coal: costing the earth.

The Barnett Government has approved three new highly polluting coal-fired power stations and reopening 2 outdated ones from the 1960's.
This decision will lock Western Australians into increasingly expensive and polluting energy for years as we bear the costs of the Barnett Government's irresponsible decisions long after the Premier and Minister Faragher have moved on.
While Australia is committed to an unconditional 5% emissions reduction by 2020, and developed countries as a whole must reduce pollution by 40% in the next ten years, our pollution under the Barnett Government is set to skyrocket.
If the environmental argument to put a stop to new coal power stations is not compelling enough, the economic argument makes these proposals look like sheer madness.
When announcing the 2010 state Budget, Premier Barnett remarked that the WA Government had 'swallowed the bitter pill' on energy pricing.
What he did not tell people was that decisions made today to build new coal power plants would lock WA families into continuously increasing electricity bills in the future. Unlike solar, wind, wave or geothermal energy sources which continue to provide almost free energy after their initial capital investment is paid off, coal power stations expose energy consumers to escalating resource costs and to the inevitable introduction of a price on carbon.
Despite this, the Barnett Government seems intent on locking us into the dirty and increasingly unaffordable technologies of the last century.
Carbon Capture & Storage: untested, unsafe, unaffordable.
The companies behind the push for more coal fired power stations in WA have said 'don’t worry, we will introduce 'carbon capture and storage technology' (CCS) – our coal will be clean!'
In reality, they have not committed to a timetable for this phantom technology to be implemented, and they expect taxpayers to pay the bill if anything goes wrong! Even the WA Environmental Protection Authority considers it is 'unlikely CCS will become technically and commercially viable in WA in the near future'.
Recently, Tim Flannery, the former Australian of the Year who previously championed CCS, said he had changed his view on the idea of capturing carbon and storing it underground saying he now believes it would be economically unachievable.
Speaking to The Age, Flannery said:
I have been a great proponent of carbon capture and storage because I believed it was just essential particularly in places like China. But … having come back from that meeting and met the world’s experts in this area, I have a less hopeful view of carbon capture and storage.
Even if CCS technology were proven, some fundamental barriers remain to its commercial adoption. It is a risky technology relying on the successful storage of liquefied carbon dioxide underground for millions of years and governments and taxpayers have to pick up the bill if something goes wrong.
The risks are not insignificant either. A report into CCS commissioned by the NSW Government in 2008 found that leakage of CO2 could degrade the quality of groundwater and have lethal effects on plants and animals. Release of CO2 back into the atmosphere could also create local health and safety concerns as CO2 in large volumes is a powerful asphyxiant.
The WA Government are proposing the construction of new coal fired power stations that rely on a technology that does not exist yet, has few supporters outside the coal industry and could have catastrophic health and environmental impacts. Worst of all, if CCS fails then WA taxpayers will yet again be forced to pick up the bill.
It is clearly time for Western Australians to send a clear message that it is unacceptable for our governments to hold our future generation’s hostage to the dirty and increasingly unaffordable dinosaurs of the last century. Instead, we should be aggressively accelerating a just transition to a clean energy economy of the future.
Leading the way.
Western Australia has an incredible abundance of renewable energy resources, placing WA as a potential leader in the emerging international clean energy economy, while providing many sustainable new jobs across our sun-drenched state.
It is now up to Western Australians like us to demand that our governments support a clean sustainable energy future for Western Australia not more polluting and unaffordable coal fired power stations.



